A federal judge, Charles Breyer, has ruled that President Donald Trump unlawfully federalized California’s National Guard members and must return control to the state. This ruling follows Trump’s deployment of troops after protests in Los Angeles regarding his immigration policies. Breyer emphasized that Trump exceeded his authority and violated the Tenth Amendment by not involving the state governor in the decision. The judge paused his order temporarily, allowing the Justice Department to appeal.

Breyer criticized Trump’s justification of using the National Guard to suppress a “rebellion,” stating that the protests did not constitute such a threat. He highlighted the importance of protecting individuals’ right to protest and expressed concern over the implication that protesting the government could be seen as rebellion. The judge also noted that the federalization of the National Guard hindered California’s ability to address other critical issues, such as combating the fentanyl trade and fighting fires.

Furthermore, Breyer temporarily barred Trump from using Marines for law enforcement activities in California, pending further arguments. A hearing is scheduled for the following week to determine the long-term implications of the temporary order. The ongoing legal battle underscores the complex relationship between federal and state powers, with implications for civil liberties and governmental authority. This story is evolving, with updates expected as the situation unfolds.