A federal court has denied the Trump administration’s appeal to depose government officials regarding the mistaken deportation of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to El Salvador. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit criticized the government’s attempt to detain residents in foreign prisons without due process. Abrego Garcia, sent to El Salvador due to an administrative error, is held in a mega prison, prompting legal action for his return to the U.S.

The Fourth Circuit’s swift ruling followed the government’s appeal of a lower court order, highlighting the contentious immigration policies. The judges expressed alarm at the government’s refusal to repatriate Abrego Garcia, emphasizing the fundamental importance of liberty in American values.

Maryland Judge Paula Xinis had previously ordered the government to ensure Abrego Garcia’s return, a decision upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court. Despite the Justice Department’s reluctance to provide details on their efforts, Judge Xinis mandated expedited discovery for Abrego Garcia’s lawyers to question officials and request documentation.

In response to the government’s appeal, the appellate court rebuked claims of judicial overreach and emphasized the need to rectify the wrongful deportation. The court urged the Executive Branch to uphold the rule of law and act in the spirit of justice. The possibility of an appeal to the Supreme Court remains open, while agency officials are required to testify under oath about their actions in facilitating Abrego Garcia’s return. This case serves as a critical test of the administration’s commitment to legal principles and human rights.