Chicago celebrated the unexpected ascension of Robert Prevost, a Chicago native, as Pope Leo XIV. Prevost’s roots in Chicago and his journey from a South Side upbringing to becoming a missionary in Peru resonated with the city’s Catholic community. The announcement sparked joy and excitement among residents, reminiscent of the Cubs’ 2016 World Series victory. Chicago’s strong Catholic presence, despite challenges such as parish consolidations and declining Christian identification, embraced the news of a hometown pope with optimism.

Local reactions varied from lighthearted jokes at hot dog stands to heartfelt prayers at Holy Name Cathedral, where attendees hoped for Pope Leo to continue Pope Francis’s inclusive and progressive approach. The community’s enthusiasm was evident in events like a mock conclave at Mount Carmel Academy and discussions about the new pope’s potential impact. Young Catholics expressed support for Pope Leo, emphasizing continuity with Pope Francis’s vision.

The surprising selection of an American pope, particularly from Chicago, symbolized a shift towards inclusivity and listening to the laity. Amidst political uncertainties, Pope Leo’s appointment inspired hope and reflection even among non-religious visitors like Kara Baekey, who sought solace and guidance in the church. The announcement brought a sense of magic and unity to Chicago, signaling a new chapter for the Catholic Church and the country.