A US-born American citizen, Juan Carlos Lopez-Gomez, was arrested and detained in a Florida county jail at the request of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (Ice), despite presenting his birth certificate in court. The judge confirmed the authenticity of the document, but Lopez-Gomez was still held due to federal authorities’ request. His mother, Sebastiana Gomez-Perez, expressed distress during a court appearance, highlighting the emotional toll of the situation.

Lopez-Gomez’s arrest occurred during a traffic stop while he was on his way to work at a construction site in Tallahassee. He was charged under Florida’s strict immigration law, SB 4C, which criminalizes undocumented immigrants over 18 years old who knowingly enter the state. However, a federal court had recently issued a temporary restraining order blocking the enforcement of this law.

After community advocate Silvia Alba presented Lopez-Gomez’s birth certificate in court, the judge dismissed the misdemeanor charge but was unable to release him immediately due to Ice’s 48-hour hold request. Ultimately, Lopez-Gomez was released on Thursday evening, eliciting relief and gratitude from supporters and activists.

The incident underscores the challenges faced by individuals, including US citizens, in the current immigration enforcement landscape. The case also raises concerns about the legality and implications of Ice detainers, with calls for greater accountability and adherence to due process for all individuals involved.