The potential candidacy of Péter Erdő, Hungary’s senior bishop, for the position of pope within the traditionalist camp raises significant considerations. Highly regarded for his expertise in church law and extensive knowledge, Erdő’s profile extends beyond Hungary due to his involvement in Vatican bodies and international Catholic conferences. While seen as a remote figure compared to Pope Francis, Erdő’s conservative stance on issues like LGBTQ+ rights and divorce aligns with traditionalist views, positioning him favorably among conservatives.

Despite his conservative leanings, Erdő presents himself as a moderate figure, distinguishing him from more polarizing traditionalist candidates. However, concerns arise regarding his close ties to Hungary’s Fidesz government, known for its controversial policies on issues such as migration and LGBTQ+ rights. Additionally, Erdő faces scrutiny for his handling of allegations of child sexual abuse within the church, raising questions about his commitment to addressing such sensitive matters.

Erdő’s potential papacy could have far-reaching implications, particularly impacting LGBTQ+ Catholics, divorced individuals, abuse survivors, and those advocating for the church’s integrity in public discourse. As Archbishop of Esztergom-Budapest, Erdő’s track record suggests a reluctance to challenge authority or address critical issues effectively. This raises doubts about his suitability to lead the Catholic Church as pope, especially in a time where progressive reforms and ethical leadership are crucial considerations.